Lyle’s rewritten half dozen verse text message is approximately parallel into songster text message just after deletion of the next verse of one’s second. Lyle’s rewritten type, yet not, provides the routine planning to Kilkenny, instead of Killarney. Lyle’s song is actually “The newest Bonnie Bluish Forget about-Me-Perhaps not,” that was considering for the R. An excellent. Smith’s Brand new Irish Minstrel , letter.d. [1825, the first, purportedly pent-up, edition]. Brand new name of the song is there offered once the “The fresh new Maid out-of Derby.” Whenever you are Lyle’s text message “Rather Peg regarding Derby” is actually worthless given that a vintage track, we are able to guarantee “Quite Peggy out-of Derby” try sung when you look at the Scotland in the 1st one-fourth of your nineteenth century with a book much like you to definitely throughout the songster. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text in place of a good chapbook otherwise broadside duplicate appears Roy Palmer’s previous Everyman’s Guide off Ballads. ]
Cahusac inside 1788, and you may a single sheet track that have sounds is in a few American stuff, “Peggy from Darby”, hence kicks off “There’s a good gay Master within the Darby Urban area”
Perhaps somewhat before “Fairly Peggy out-of Derby, O” was rewritten while the “This new Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” as evidenced of the a duplicate within the Peter Buchan’s MSS on the Uk Collection, which happen to be considered time throughout the 1828.
The original line and a half, nearly exactly like those individuals above, are also during the a beneficial medley for the Vol. I, p. cuatro, 1825. You can find music for the song “Fairly Peggy from Derby, O” to your p. 107 and you may 276 away from Vol. III, 1828, and the first-line of “Peggy from Darby” is during a good medley into p. 284.
Lyle together with composed another tune to your track, offered from the really works cited, and you may published earlier that have audio
T. Crofton Crocker on Prominent Tunes off Ireland , London, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 from 1886 reprint), states, “The fresh rather Maid from Derby, O!” is proven to be the production of an enthusiastic Irishman, but become brings zero particulars whichever, not really mentioning where a duplicate of the text message otherwise song could well be discovered. It seems that Crocker expected his members becoming common on song and you can tune. The evidence quoted a lot more than seems to me to be somewhat conclusive for taking “Fairly Peggy out-of Derby” is an enthusiastic Irish song and you will tune. Lacking so it evidence, yet not, there have been counterclaims. Wm. Chappell within the Popular music of your Olden Day , II, p. 771, detailed Crocker’s allege, but meant the tune was not Irish, yet not, he offered no direct proof. Chappell’s report you to definitely Bunting refuted it is instead of basis. Bunting don’t mention the fresh song, which is most certainly not just like stating the guy refused it. Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs having Chappell in the article on Irish Folk-music from inside the new fifth ed. regarding Grove’s Dictionary , but alludes to no evidence pro or scam, so we don’t know exactly what facts he previously viewed, or no.
Lastly, two situations We haven’t yet , viewed. There is certainly a copy of your own tune in a great flute teacher authored by T. BUCEM listing zero content regarding the in the Uk Countries.
Unrelated: “Falls of Brandy” try a much earlier not related tune out-of equivalent term, often referred to as “Dribbles regarding Brandy.” Aforementioned name Thomson’s song on the tune in his Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Distressed Gallant’, 1738. A couple of years later on which track is copied on the NLS MS 6299. The brand new song you are going to violation to the fresh you to definitely towards tune when we didn’t know that the fresh new song are before. “The fresh Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s song to have his song “More youthful Can get Moon” in the 5th level of Irish Tunes , letter.d. is a separate pay attention six/8 go out with identical label, evidently provided by JuЕѕnoafriДЌka dame iz daleka Moore from the chorus of a tune in Robin Bonnet where the song featured in place of identity.