Brand new mention of the “Tom Bombodil” since Voldemort’s actual label in addition to suggests that Tara try a good troll, once the name is in line with the profile Tom Bombadil off The lord of Groups

While the the Los Angeles, CA girls for marriage father of one’s Rings is actually hardly Goth material even by Tara’s shed definition of Blond, and Tom Bombadil just appeared in the book type of Brand new Lord of your Bands (and you may Tara isn’t an enormous audience because evidenced because of the their particular claiming to not have check out the entire Harry Potter show and you may their own worst spelling), it is not easy to explain just how Tara would’ve identified throughout the him, while if Tara are an excellent troll it could’ve without difficulty come an excellent cheeky site.

In addition, My Immortal alone, for a lack of a much better reasons, does unnecessary things wrong it’s close impractical to become taken seriously.

It checks out such as for example a summary of one thing an excellent troll creator create do: appear to misspell words into the an almost organized manner, text message messaging, random/unexplained sex moments, high OOC, etc

While doing so, to negate the newest troll concept, you must need into the account of all issues that is an integral part of My Immortal. The brand new trolling copywriter would have to create the identity out-of Tara Gilesbie, do their own of a lot accounts (this lady has got other accounts in addition to the one that’s today removed off ), and her password(s), and not to refer spend some time and you can commitment to build the brand new 40-four part enough time facts alone.

And Tara Gilesbie, the brand new troll author would also need to recall the image regarding Raven, Tara Gilesbie’s pal. Like in Tara’s instance, the fresh new troll will have to create Raven’s membership(s), password(s), and you can make her tales, except if there clearly was a second troll with it. Raven’s stories would have to correspond that have Tara’s stories, as they got a receding. Both publishers has actually sections within fan fictions where they each other authored (otherwise murdered) off the avatars within their reports established off the almost every other writer’s personalities and you may vice-versa. Along with, Raven’s account along with her earliest facts are built prior to Tara got actually already been their unique account, which means troll creator could have had to have been with the idea of Tara (as this woman is said in the first section away from I am not saying Okay) while composing a different sort of story when you look at the a new build in check to pull off of the trolling.

This could be much, for even a troll. Incase Tara are a beneficial troll, she could easily be a very computed and chronic troll so you can manage both of these membership. Or it could had been a well prepared group whom made a decision to set My personal Immortal to each other. The options try limitless.

To have unknown factors, people attended forward and you will reported themselves to have written and/otherwise co-written My personal Immortal. Some have chosen to take it further of the saying that they are or created the persona out of Tara Gilesbie and admitted which they was basically trolling and you may composing new stories having humor. Particular have gone to disturbingly great extremes in order to say that it not just was indeed Tara, however, had been continuing this new legacy out of My Immortal because of the composing the brand new tales much like the manner of one’s amazing tale by post for example reports into (even though some features after that come erased). Whether these people are lying or telling the truth is yet another mystery, once the some body have effortlessly written a merchant account and you can reported My Immortal as their very own. The reality that any of these people have chose to been pass at all such decades anywhere between today and 2007 are doubtful sufficient, however it is the up to have discussion or over on reader/customer to find the credibility of your facts in their brain. Some tips about what causes my Immortal probably one of the most mysterious bits of works the internet has previously viewed.